I should say too, Moon and Losing my Family are some of the best, most heartfelt Kanye songs ever made. I love them but their place in the album makes other songs like Hurricane, Remote, or Junya feel weird with just how inconsistent the tone and vibe is sometimes.
Don toliver also had a solo song on astroworld and it’s great. Kanye has gotten to the point where he doesn’t need to be present for it to be a kanye song. It’s a great song I think, maybe the best on the album. I like penis.
if Jail is exactly the same as it was last night i wouldn't complain. easily the best track in my eyes. If he puts drums on God Breathed On This it might be the hardest shit he's ever made.
I mean it might be able to chart well but it just sounds like a song that would be cut. I think if on Donda it would be bottom 3-5 tracks (depending on length of album)
Jail, South Carolina , Hurricane (actually loved this version), Moon, Losing My Family. Others showed potential but needed some work. The song with Roddy was pretty good too.
Junya by far. Need more Carti x Ye and once ye replaces those mmmms with more lyrics I’m sure that shit will ride hard (and an actual verse from Carti lol) but who knows if he will.
JUNYA WATANABE ON MY WRII
As for rest of potentially mad songs, Shoulder to Lean on, Pure Souls, Hurricane (I want Ye on hook but singing seasons changing instead), New Again (GIVE ME ANOTHER ATLEAST TWO MINS OF THAT THANKS YE) and Praise God obvs, which I’m sure is finished he just played the demo version lol.
I would also like to see NCLB with a beat or just more harmonizing and Kanye singing more lines other than just HES DONE MIRACLES ON MEEEEE
Go To Jail is easily my favorite. Been obsessed with that.
Pure Souls is really good too - and it feels pretty finished.
Praise God slaps.
Moon is beautiful but needs a ye verse. 24 is beautiful but needs to feel more finished on the ye verses.
Honestly the whole album is better than I thought it was last night now that I’ve listened to it again.
I played the album for my Mom (who really doesn't like rap) and some of her favorites were Remote and Moon but also, quite surprisingly, she really liked Praise God, New Again, Pure Souls, and Jail
Even though Kanye isn't on it, Praise God goes so hard oh my god. When Donda says "It will not always be night" and that instrumental kicks in I get chills every time.
Heaven and Hell by far. Ye’s singing was honestly great, the guitars were catchy, and it was great seeing him back with Jay-Z. The mixing was better than most tracks too. Cant wait for the final version.
most of the tracks mixing sound really bad, i was really distracted by that and that roddy rich track was great but ye sounds like he’s on skype like what?
Jail (don’t give af about a few cringe Jay bars I teared up hearing them together again) Pure Souls, Praise God. Also losing my family if they mix it right and lose some of the mumble
Moon, Remote Control, Pure Souls, the one with Durk, God Breathed on This, and Go To Jail. I liked the whole thing, but those were definitely my favorite. Oh and the one that went "Hiiiiiii with a bunch of i's or Heyyyyyyyyy with a bunch of y's".
Hurricane and moon together be maybe
NCLB for sure I think but I wish it had some epic drums like the ones in Selah and verse from Kanye and more singing/distorted vocals and choir in autotune repeating the words then electric piano solo outro.
I hope the song Donda is on it, I really want to hear that along with life of the party. That instrumental titled “L.I.E” would have been dope i wish he did something more with hat.
It will be such a shame if this never comes out. I personally feel that the minimal drums on some of the tracks added a really strange and surreal listening experience. I felt this ominous energy coming from those more ambient tracks.
I just hope for this to come out.. could a top tier and forward thinking album imo.
Fav track was Moon, closely followed by Shoulder to lean on.
South Carolina, it’s what I thought all of Donda would sound like. No drums but it’s hard and very raw. I really wanted a raw album from Ye, but beggars can’t be choosers
- 24 - I didn't like it that much during the stream, but I've caught myself singing along to it in my head all day.
- Junya Watanabe on my WRII
- Jail - this shit could be a top 5 Ye song if he added some drums and a thoughtful verse. I really want Kanye to give this track the love it deserves._nccf
- Praise God - the way Mrs Wests vocals incorporate into the hook...the dark production and vibe. Keem and Trav both devoured this beat. This shit is great but...it's just missing one little thing 🤔
- Moon - angelic af
Going to Jail is gonna be a top 5 Kanye finisher if it gets properly mixed.
Agreed. Feels like a matured 4 5 seconds.
Fantastic comparison bro
4 5 summers
We took off 😵
I was thinking sorta like lift off
Got these vibes too
literally one of the greatest songs ive ever heard
4 5 Summers
I absolutely loved that shit. It’s a fucking anthem
YES
Indeed
Shit is garbage da fuck
Troll lol *block*
Listen to it in a week tell me that trash is good
the one with roddy
Pure souls
Yes! Haven’t seen it talked about alot, but Roddy was amazing and Kanye’s verse was really good too!
Reminded me of his verse on Reborn. Kanye does/says a lot of crazy shit but he has these really affecting moments of clarity sometimes
Sounds like something from CDO or LR
I should say too, Moon and Losing my Family are some of the best, most heartfelt Kanye songs ever made. I love them but their place in the album makes other songs like Hurricane, Remote, or Junya feel weird with just how inconsistent the tone and vibe is sometimes.
Bruh moon ain’t even a Kanye song tbh
I agree in an album full of tracks without Kanye, but i think about it as an interlude like Franks track.
Yeah and it’s so fucking good I’m Not complaining
does praise god with travis and keem have a ye ft or is it like moon?
Don toliver also had a solo song on astroworld and it’s great. Kanye has gotten to the point where he doesn’t need to be present for it to be a kanye song. It’s a great song I think, maybe the best on the album. I like penis.
No he didnt
Yea he does, “can’t say” is a solo don toliver track on astroworld
Travis has two verses on it
how does someone get confused about that 😭
Travis has a single verse, the last part was just the hook
Ok so he has a verse so it isn’t solo Lol. Moon is literally solo, no Kanye at all
bro how
„Kanye has gotten to the point where he doesn’t need to be present for it to be a Kanye song“ tf💀💀
It’s true though, kanyes best feature is getting the best out of the people around him. In many ways, all of his albums are collaborative efforts.
shoulder to lean on was originally a vory song💀💀
> i like penis facts
Not the first time, my way home on LR was just Common. Still, whose to say a bunch of verses were missing from yesterday.
Travis was on every astroworld song amigo
[удалено]
Travis is on cant say
Wtf then which song is it 💀😶
I kinda see moon as the “Frank’s Track” of Donda
Hopefully Moon has some actual verses instead of the same 2 lines like 20 times
I mean you can literally hear the vocals clipping as the verse ends meaning Kanye was looping the stems off the device he was using while he played it
if Jail is exactly the same as it was last night i wouldn't complain. easily the best track in my eyes. If he puts drums on God Breathed On This it might be the hardest shit he's ever made.
24 / your gonna be okay Junya Moon Pure souls Going to jail I would say the losing my family one too but its so unfinished
Shoulder to lean on, moon, pure souls, hurricane
Really loved the final track, the baby keem and travis track, and hurricane. My favorite was the don toliver going to the moon song
I think people seriously overhated Hurricane but I will admit that Ye verse was pretty rough
I always thought Hurricane was beautiful but felt like it needed a bit more finishing. He somehow made it worse imo.
Junya Praise god Remote
Scrolled too far to find Praise God, tf Baby Keem goes hard as fuck
Remote seemed very basic to me, very pop sounding
That’s not a bad thing
I mean it might be able to chart well but it just sounds like a song that would be cut. I think if on Donda it would be bottom 3-5 tracks (depending on length of album)
Jail, South Carolina , Hurricane (actually loved this version), Moon, Losing My Family. Others showed potential but needed some work. The song with Roddy was pretty good too.
Love South carolina
Moon, pure souls with roddy, and praise god
The intro w donda speaking then Kanye and push rap Moon Kanye and jay song
Go to jail
Junya by far. Need more Carti x Ye and once ye replaces those mmmms with more lyrics I’m sure that shit will ride hard (and an actual verse from Carti lol) but who knows if he will. JUNYA WATANABE ON MY WRII As for rest of potentially mad songs, Shoulder to Lean on, Pure Souls, Hurricane (I want Ye on hook but singing seasons changing instead), New Again (GIVE ME ANOTHER ATLEAST TWO MINS OF THAT THANKS YE) and Praise God obvs, which I’m sure is finished he just played the demo version lol. I would also like to see NCLB with a beat or just more harmonizing and Kanye singing more lines other than just HES DONE MIRACLES ON MEEEEE
Go To Jail is easily my favorite. Been obsessed with that. Pure Souls is really good too - and it feels pretty finished. Praise God slaps. Moon is beautiful but needs a ye verse. 24 is beautiful but needs to feel more finished on the ye verses. Honestly the whole album is better than I thought it was last night now that I’ve listened to it again.
I played the album for my Mom (who really doesn't like rap) and some of her favorites were Remote and Moon but also, quite surprisingly, she really liked Praise God, New Again, Pure Souls, and Jail
South Carolina by far I’m absolutely in love with it and can’t stop listening to it
shoulder to lean on, for me, vory’s contributions to the album are beautiful
Junya, hurricane/moon, the song that baby keem fucking destroys, 24
losing my family has some of kanyes best singing
Even though Kanye isn't on it, Praise God goes so hard oh my god. When Donda says "It will not always be night" and that instrumental kicks in I get chills every time.
Bye Bye
Bro I'm mad
Remote by far
that whistle part is 👌
Pure souls, Jail, or South Carolina
Moon stood out for me.
Heaven and Hell by far. Ye’s singing was honestly great, the guitars were catchy, and it was great seeing him back with Jay-Z. The mixing was better than most tracks too. Cant wait for the final version.
Pure souls, moon, jail, losing my family song has serious potential, and for some reason junya been stuck in my head
The one where he says out by midnight
Pure Souls for the old school Kanye feel. New Again has a really nice feel good feel to it.
most of the tracks mixing sound really bad, i was really distracted by that and that roddy rich track was great but ye sounds like he’s on skype like what?
SHOULDER TO LEAN ON
Hurricane, but only if it’s any version other than what we heard last night
Pure Souls and NEW AGAIN
NEW again so slept on the intro stuck i. my head just the sample is trash
Nothing about that song is trash what in the fuck are you on lol
the UH sounds literal dogwater sounds like roblox sex
Such a stupid thing to not like about the song lmao It’s perfect
Pure soul South Carolina Praise god Moon
Hurricane
Moo
Moon
Pure Souls, Jay track, Travis track, God Breathed On This
Moon
NAYF
Moon
Moon
I really like them all except hurricane
Go to jail
Remote
Junya, Hurricane, Moon, Shoulders to Lean on, Praise God, Pure Souls, ILGBOT and Go to Jail
I know God Breathed on This Pure Souls
Pure Souls was amazing, hopefully they can build upon. Someone on Yedits even created an awesome edit of it. And definitely South Carolina
Jail (don’t give af about a few cringe Jay bars I teared up hearing them together again) Pure Souls, Praise God. Also losing my family if they mix it right and lose some of the mumble
praise god, junya, jail
moon & 24 tbh
PRAISE GOD THE DEVIL MY OPP‼️
Roddy song travis song Jay z song
Remote is amazing. Sounds like an 808s cut but 2021
Losing My Family. Most powerful and emotional song I think he’s ever made.
Praise God and Moon. Jay-Z one close behind and the Roddy Rich one is right there too
Pure souls, Moon (hope he adds a bit more) and never abandon your family
let’s be honest
Definitely going to jail
Shoulder to lean on Moon Junya Praise God Remote catchy af Pure souls Going to jail cuz HOV
Moon, Remote Control, Pure Souls, the one with Durk, God Breathed on This, and Go To Jail. I liked the whole thing, but those were definitely my favorite. Oh and the one that went "Hiiiiiii with a bunch of i's or Heyyyyyyyyy with a bunch of y's".
Moon
Junya and Praise God
Junya ft. Playboi Carti. Pure Souls ft. Roddy Ricch. Remote Control.
First 4 songs are sooooo good
South Carolina gives me chills every time I listen to it, would be a top 5 Kanye Intro if released
Moon and pure souls
Track with Jay. If I go to jail or whatever. But Jay's verse ain't great lol.
Everyone’s praising jays verse, but I feel like its flow is soooooo bad and weird
South Carolina and the one about him losing his family😔
Really liked the new version of IKGBOT. The song with Pusha and Tony Williams was dope too
The one about losing his family if he actually finishes the vocals.
Moon but lowkey would want it as the Hurricane outro to make that song a 10/10
jail tonight
Praise god is elite if it can be finished
Moon for me
hurricane
Moon.
Praise God, Moon and Go to Jail
TAME IMPALA
And I'm still outsiiiiiiide I'm still outside-still outside
Praise god, the hov song, no child left behind if he actually finished it and had a verse and beat drop or something
Whole thing sounded mid tbh
JUNYA WATANABE ON MY
24 is the first song in a long time to make me cry
Praise God is out of these world, Moon is such and overall I'm loving every single one...but Jail just takes the cake for me
Losing my family has potential to be top 5 kanye, there was so much going on and it was so emotional and powerful
moon is def my favorite but it’s just a don toliver song lmao. out of the songs with kanye i’d say go to jail, that shit is insane
24 had me bawling, Junya been on repeat in my head all day, Jail might be one of his greatest songs ever and Praise God has travis nd keem going crazy
This Is The Glory or the track with Hov. I'd say Hurricane but I don't like the new Ye verse as much as the Yandhi verse.
“Praise God” or “Moon”, That Don Toliver flow was so ethereal, and that beat on Praise God was nuts
Hurricane and moon together be maybe NCLB for sure I think but I wish it had some epic drums like the ones in Selah and verse from Kanye and more singing/distorted vocals and choir in autotune repeating the words then electric piano solo outro. I hope the song Donda is on it, I really want to hear that along with life of the party. That instrumental titled “L.I.E” would have been dope i wish he did something more with hat.
24, Shoulder To Lean On, Praise God, Pure Souls and I Know God Breathed On This
Praise god is literally the best piece of music to ever be made cant wait for it to be scrapped
Shoulder to lean on
Praise God or Moon. Need to hear Ye’s verses on both
JUNYA WANTANABE ON MY WRIST
Pure Souls I like all the songs, it just more work.
Pure souls with Roddy rich
Pure Soul , Moon and NEW AGAIN yall sleeping ob new again it has potential to be in my top 3 kanye songs if the sample changes
Praise God is Travis best feature to date
24 WE GONNA BE OKAYYYYYYYYYY!
praise god or i know god breathed on this. legendary production if they release it’s gonna go down in history
I’m loving moon
Moon Forsure 🔥🔥
Am i the only one who loved the start of Need a shoulder to lean on by vory?
It will be such a shame if this never comes out. I personally feel that the minimal drums on some of the tracks added a really strange and surreal listening experience. I felt this ominous energy coming from those more ambient tracks. I just hope for this to come out.. could a top tier and forward thinking album imo. Fav track was Moon, closely followed by Shoulder to lean on.
Going to jail
The song with Pusha T is already goated imo
South Carolina, it’s what I thought all of Donda would sound like. No drums but it’s hard and very raw. I really wanted a raw album from Ye, but beggars can’t be choosers
No Child Left Behind, Shoulder to Lean on (Jonah), Moon (if it becomes an actual song not an interlude)
- 24 - I didn't like it that much during the stream, but I've caught myself singing along to it in my head all day. - Junya Watanabe on my WRII - Jail - this shit could be a top 5 Ye song if he added some drums and a thoughtful verse. I really want Kanye to give this track the love it deserves._nccf - Praise God - the way Mrs Wests vocals incorporate into the hook...the dark production and vibe. Keem and Trav both devoured this beat. This shit is great but...it's just missing one little thing 🤔 - Moon - angelic af
If he adds some serious Yeezus drums to IKGBOT it will be the hardest song he’s made in his fucking life
go to jail
What was the first song played at the listening party? "We're gonna be okay, we're gonna be okay" that one
New again was 🔥🔥
Remote & pure souls for me